Skip to content
GarnerDocs

Compare

GarnerDocs vs email attachments.

Email is free, and every client already knows how to attach a file. Here's what it costs you in chasing time and risk once you collect from more than a few clients.

Facts checked · Reviewed every six months

Email

GarnerDocs

Example · sample data

Our take

For a handful of clients a year, email is enough. Past that, chasing becomes someone's job, and GarnerDocs takes it over.

The short version: four differences.

What changes when you stop collecting by email.

Chasing

Email
You write and send each reminder
GarnerDocs
Sent on a schedule, and they stop once nothing is outstanding

Knowing what's missing

Email
A spreadsheet you update by hand
GarnerDocs
Every request's progress on one page

Wrong files

Email
Another email, lost in a reply-all thread
GarnerDocs
A replacement request, with a note on that document

Where copies sit

Email
In inboxes on both sides, until someone deletes them
GarnerDocs
Private storage, deleted after your retention period

Which fits you

Pick the one that fits how you work.

Choose GarnerDocs if…

  • You ask many clients for the same kinds of documents.
  • You lose time working out who still owes you what.
  • You write the same reminder emails every week.
  • You want client files deleted on a schedule, not kept in inboxes.
Start your free trial

From $39 a month, or $390 a year · 14 days free

Stay with email if…

  • You collect from a handful of clients a year.
  • Each request is one or two files, sent once.
  • You don't need to see progress across clients.
  • You'd rather not pay for another tool.
When email is still the better choice

Side by side

Every stage, compared.

What each approach does at every stage of collecting documents from a client.

Asking

What your client has to do

GarnerDocs
Yes. Open a link in an email. No account or password
Email and a spreadsheet
Yes. Reply with attachments. No account either

One list of what's needed

GarnerDocs
Yes. A checklist for each request, from a template
Email and a spreadsheet
No. Typed into each email

Chasing

Knowing what's missing

GarnerDocs
Yes. Every request's progress on one page
Email and a spreadsheet
No. A spreadsheet you update by hand

Reminders

GarnerDocs
Yes. Sent on a schedule you set once
Email and a spreadsheet
No. You write and send each one

When reminders stop

GarnerDocs
Yes. Once nothing is outstanding. Each one lists only what's still missing
Email and a spreadsheet
No. When someone remembers to stop

Reviewing

A wrong or unreadable file

GarnerDocs
Yes. Ask for a replacement, with a note shown next to that document
Email and a spreadsheet
No. Another email, often lost in a reply-all thread

Who approved what, and when

GarnerDocs
Yes. Each approval and replacement request in the request's history
Email and a spreadsheet
No. Spread across people's inboxes

A back-and-forth conversation

GarnerDocs
No. Notes on each document, not a chat thread
Email and a spreadsheet
Yes. Reply as often as you like

Keeping files

File size

GarnerDocs
Up to 25 MB per file, shown before your client uploads
Email and a spreadsheet
A limit on the whole message, set by each email provider and often around 20–25 MB

Where files end up

GarnerDocs
Yes. Filed under the client, the request and the document
Email and a spreadsheet
No. In whichever inbox they arrived in

Who in your team can see them

GarnerDocs
Yes. Your team, in one place, after signing in
Email and a spreadsheet
No. Whoever received the email, or was forwarded it

Security

Where copies sit

GarnerDocs
Yes. Private storage, opened through a permission check
Email and a spreadsheet
No. In inboxes and sent folders on both sides

Files deleted after a set period

GarnerDocs
Yes. 30, 90, 180 or 365 days, and the client's link closes
Email and a spreadsheet
No. Kept until someone deletes them

Cost

Price

GarnerDocs
From $39 a month, or $390 a year, with a 14-day free trial
Email and a spreadsheet
Yes. Free with the email you already have

See the difference

What email can't do for you.

Chasing

Reminders that write themselves, and stop.

By default 3 and 7 days after sending, and 3 days before the due date. Each lists only what's still missing.

How automatic reminders work

Reviewing

Wrong file? Say so on the document.

Ask for a replacement with a note your client sees next to that document, not in a reply-all thread.

Ask a client for a replacement file

Keeping files safe

Out of inboxes, then deleted on time.

Out of inboxes and sent folders. When your retention period ends, files are deleted and the link closes.

How long files are kept

The hidden cost of chasing by email

Email costs nothing to send. The cost is in the work around it. You type out the list for every client. Each reply means opening the attachments, checking them against the list and updating the spreadsheet that tracks who still owes you what. When a client goes quiet, you work out what's missing, then write the reminder by hand.

That's fine for five clients. With forty clients and ten documents each, it becomes someone's job. Then come the wrong files: a blurry photo, last year's statement, page one of three. Each means another email and another wait.

Where attachments go

An emailed document ends up in several places: the inbox of whoever received it, your client's sent folder, every forward and someone's downloads folder. Nothing deletes those copies when the work is done, so IDs, payslips and bank statements stay in mailboxes for years.

Size is the other problem. Each email provider limits the size of a whole message, often to around 20–25 MB, so a long scan gets split across several emails, or bounces. In GarnerDocs each file can be up to 25 MB, and your client sees that limit before they upload. The security page covers where files are kept and who can open them.

What changes for your clients

Very little, which is the point. Your client still gets an email from you, with a link to their own upload page instead of a list to reply to.

They can upload from a phone or a computer, send some files today and the rest next week, and leave a note. See what your clients see.

When email is still the better choice

If each request is one or two files sent once, a reply with an attachment is quicker than setting anything up, and it's free.

Email is also a conversation, and GarnerDocs isn't: there are notes on each document, but no chat thread, so keep talking to clients by email. GarnerDocs doesn't do e-signatures or engagement letters, and it isn't practice management or a CRM. If you want one system for all of that, an all-in-one suite may suit you better.

Moving over

There's nothing to migrate. Finish the collections you've started by email, and send the next batch from GarnerDocs.

  1. Make a template

    Turn the list you usually type into an email into a template.

  2. Add your clients

    One at a time, or from a spreadsheet.

  3. Send the requests

    Create a request for each client and send it. The reminders take it from there.

Plans start at $39 a month, or $390 a year, for 20 active requests on Starter, and every new workspace starts with a 14-day free trial, no card needed. See pricing.

Questions

Do my clients need an account or an app?

No. Each request has its own private link, sent to your client in an email from your firm. They open it on a phone or computer and upload. There's nothing to install and no password to set up or forget.

Is a private link safer than an email attachment?

It removes some of email's risks. The file isn't copied into inboxes, sent folders and forwards, and it's deleted when your retention period ends, which also closes the link. Each link is a random code that opens one request only. It can't protect a client's own device or email account.

What if a client has a file bigger than 25 MB?

Each file can be up to 25 MB, and your client sees that limit next to each document before they upload. A large scan can usually be saved at a lower quality or split into parts, and a document can take more than one file.

Can I still email my clients?

Yes. GarnerDocs sends the request and the reminders; your inbox stays for everything else. If a client emails a document anyway, reply with their link so the file lands in the right place.

How we checked

GarnerDocs features are checked against the product, and prices come from our pricing page. Facts last checked . We review this page every six months.

Spend less time chasing. More time doing the work that matters.

Make document collection the easiest part of working with your clients.

Start your free trial

No credit card required.